Coolest Super Mario Cake

This Super Mario cake was made using 1 package of yellow cake mix, according to the directions. For baking, I used 2 round pans (8 in.) and a dozen cupcakes. The round pans were less than 1/2 full, as my kids like cake that’s heavy on the frosting anyway!

The face is one of the rounds, and the hat is made by cutting a moon shape from the other round. The ears, chin and nose were made by carving up a few of the cupcakes to size.

I mixed colors to get the skin tone. The brown is homemade chocolate frosting. The red, black and blue are Wilton squeeze tubes from the grocery store (the kind you can buy tips for and screw ’em right on-super handy!)

I used the star tip on the hat and the round tip for fill in and outlining. If I had it to do over, I would have left the outlining off of the eyes. The CG Mario in all the new games has more of a 3D look without outlining, so that would have portrayed him more accurately.

We had an excited bunch when this guy was unveiled! It took me about an hour to decorate.


23 thoughts on “Coolest Super Mario Cake”

  1. Thank you for sharing….I was shocked at the prices people wanted on eBay for the Mario cake pans.

    Your recipe saved the day.

    My nephew will love it….I prepared it last night and was truly amazed as too how simple it was to put together.

    Reply
  2. I saw your cake online and absolutely Loved it. I made it this evening for my son’s 4th birthday and it turned out fantastic!
    Thank You for sharing your picture and ideas.

    Reply
  3. I baked 4 round cakes and cut out the large moon shape for the hat and 3 small moon shape for the ears and chin. Then I cut a circle for the nose. It is in the freezer for next week frosting.

    Reply
  4. I made this cake today for my son’s sixth birthday party and it turned out so cute!! Super easy for me who is an amateur at cake decorating. Thanks so much for the idea and instructions!

    Reply
  5. I made this cake for my son’s 8th birthday. The instructions were so clear that the cake came out exactly as the picture. Thank you for the idea.

    Reply
  6. Searching the internet for a Mario cake (my son’s turning 8) that’s adorable and relatively simple. This is perfect! I think I can confidentially put this together. Thanks for the help!!

    Reply
  7. This idea was fantastic. It saved the birthday party as I had to make it the same day. I sped up the process by using 2 Bear Paws for the mustache which looked amazing, I only had to trim them a little to get them closer to his nose. And instead of outlining his hat with icing, I used Nibs to give it a 3-D look all along his forehead. His eyebrows were made of cut-up black licorice. The kids loved it. Thank you for the fabulous idea and picture.

    Reply
  8. Thanks so much for sharing…my grandson wants a Mario cake for his 5th birthday and begged me to make it. I usually use the shaped cake pans but refuse to pay $60 for that pan. I am so glad I won”t have to disappoint him. Great Job!

    Reply
  9. Mario cakes are hard to find or even order. I just made this today for my son’s 8th birthday and it’s perfect- he is thrilled! I’m so grateful that you shared this wonderful idea! Thank-you so very much!

    Reply

Leave a Comment