First, thank you for this website! It has been a tremendous tool and inspiration when designing cakes! I started this Cookie Monster Cake with a 9×13 cake and trimmed off the slight dome. I added the picture by using one I found on-line and tracing it onto the cake. I first traced the outside of … Read more

I started this Cookie Monster Birthday Cake by baking a single layer chocolate 10 inch square cake and a white cake in the Wilton wonder mold cake pan. I made the head with using Rice Krispie treats shaped in the ball pan. I frosted the square cake with white frosting then assembled “Cookie” by carving … Read more

For my son’s 2nd birthday I decided to do a Cookie Monster cake since he loves Sesame St. and especially Elmo and Cookie Monster. After searching online, I decided to combine a few of my favorite ideas to get the 3D cake I was looking for. I don’t have any special cake pans, so I … Read more

This Cookie Monster Birthday Cake is such a simple cake. I recommend it for anyone who is trying cake decorating for the first time! I used the Wilton Elmo Cake Pan. When the cake was cooled, I just cut off the nose (Cookie Monster doesn’t have a nose). I did the white eyes first, then … Read more

This was made from 2 9 x 13 cakes. I froze the cakes before carving. I used online pics of other cakes and free handed the shape on paper then placed on top of the two cakes to cut out his shape. I used the trimmings to make his hand. I did a crumb frosting … Read more

First, I baked two standard round cake layers for this Cookie Monster Cake. I used a standard yellow cake mix. Next, I baked both halves of the Wilton Soccer Ball Sphere Pan. I used Betty Crocker Triple Chocolate Fudge cake mix plus a package of chocolate jello instant pudding mix to “dense it up”. If … Read more

I have always made my own birthday cakes but just normal chocolate or Victoria sponges…but this year my daughter who was about to turn 15 asked if I could do her a Cookie Monster Cake. Am not one to turn down a challenge so set to Google for ideas – this site was invaluable but … Read more

My son was so in love with Cookie Monster that we made him a Cookie Monster Birthday Cake for his birthday. We started the cake by following the instructions on the cake box (whatever flavor you like). We used 2 boxes of cake mix. You will need 2 containers of white frosting and food coloring. … Read more

The cake batter is Dunkin Hines French Vanilla and I added mini chocolate chips to the batter (notice the smile). I used two round 9 inch cake pans. I used one round cake for the face and then cut two side slivers off the other circle for the “football” shaped head. I made two cupcakes … Read more

My boyfriend who is 31 this year is a massive cookie monster fan (you are never too old!) so I decided to make him a Homemade Cookie Monster Birthday Cake after seeing all the other cool cookie monster cakes out there. I started by using Betty Crocker’s Super Moist Butter Cake mix. I figured I … Read more