Thanks so much for the pony cake ideas! I cheated a little bit with my daughter’s 6th pony party birthday cake. I just bought a giant chocolate slab cake from the supermarket as the base as we had a lot of people to feed at the party and I didn’t have a cake tin big … Read more

I made this Mule Cake cake for my grandfather’s 90th birthday celebration as requested by my father. This is the 2nd original cake I’ve ever made. I searched and searched for a mule cake but could only find horse cakes, so I’m posting this in case there’s anyone else that might need a mule cake! … Read more

This Horse Birthday Cake Idea was made for a friend’s daughter’s second birthday. We began with a vanilla slab cake as the base and then a chocolate cake for the spiral cake part. We then put graham crackers around the sides of the spiral cake to make it look like dirt. The horses were made … Read more

I made this cake for my oldest daughter’s 3rd birthday (in 2009). She really wanted a pony cake and after scratching my head over how I might manage that, my sister-in-law sent me a photo of a pony cake you could get from a supermarket in the UK which I thought looked cute but pretty … Read more

This horse cake was for my sister’s 22nd birthday. She loves horses so I knew I had to make it with a horse. I used a Wiltons rectangular cake pan 11×18. I mixed two cake mixes for this size pan. I lined the pan with wax paper so that after the cake was cooked it … Read more

I made this Pony cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday party. She loves horses and so we did a cowgirl theme. I tried to match the colors of the cake details to the decorations. My husband contributed by making me a template which I then traced onto the cake. I have extra large cookie sheets … Read more

My 6 year old loves horses so this is my 4th horse cake. They keep getting better but hopefully her next will be better yet. This one is made out of a rectangle cake. Cut out the ear, make a neck line, and trim it to have a nose and back of neck. I used … Read more

I made this Horse Birthday Cake Idea for my three kids, boy 2, boy 5 and girl 7 birthday party. They all have their birthdays in August so we do a group party. All three kids LOVE horses and love the movie Toy Story. After not being able to find a shaped pan that I … Read more

My daughter and I worked together to make this Jumping Horse Birthday Cake for her 11th birthday. It is made from (2) homemade 9×13 sheet cakes. We froze one layer – wrapped in foil then wrapped in plastic wrap. My daughter used a 9×13 piece of paper to draw a jumping horse. We cut it … Read more

I got the idea for this Horse Birthday Cake from here. I enlarged the blank sketch, printed it and taped it together. I used 2 frozen 11×14 cakes that I froze. I laid the printout on them and cut it out. My 19 yr old and I spent 4 hours on this cake. We iced … Read more

I was inspired by a professional cake in a magazine and decided to attempt my own amateur version, and was delighted with the results and thought I would share this Pony Birthday Cake with anyone looking for great pony cake ideas. I used a Betty Crocker cake mix and 2 standard 9″ cake pans. I … Read more