I made this cake for my oldest daughter’s 3rd birthday (in 2009). She really wanted a pony cake and after scratching my head over how I might manage that, my sister-in-law sent me a photo of a pony cake you could get from a supermarket in the UK which I thought looked cute but pretty … Read more

This horse cake was for my sister’s 22nd birthday. She loves horses so I knew I had to make it with a horse. I used a Wiltons rectangular cake pan 11×18. I mixed two cake mixes for this size pan. I lined the pan with wax paper so that after the cake was cooked it … Read more

I made this Pony cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday party. She loves horses and so we did a cowgirl theme. I tried to match the colors of the cake details to the decorations. My husband contributed by making me a template which I then traced onto the cake. I have extra large cookie sheets … Read more

My 6 year old loves horses so this is my 4th horse cake. They keep getting better but hopefully her next will be better yet. This one is made out of a rectangle cake. Cut out the ear, make a neck line, and trim it to have a nose and back of neck. I used … Read more

I made this Horse Birthday Cake Idea for my three kids, boy 2, boy 5 and girl 7 birthday party. They all have their birthdays in August so we do a group party. All three kids LOVE horses and love the movie Toy Story. After not being able to find a shaped pan that I … Read more

My daughter and I worked together to make this Jumping Horse Birthday Cake for her 11th birthday. It is made from (2) homemade 9×13 sheet cakes. We froze one layer – wrapped in foil then wrapped in plastic wrap. My daughter used a 9×13 piece of paper to draw a jumping horse. We cut it … Read more

I got the idea for this Horse Birthday Cake from here. I enlarged the blank sketch, printed it and taped it together. I used 2 frozen 11×14 cakes that I froze. I laid the printout on them and cut it out. My 19 yr old and I spent 4 hours on this cake. We iced … Read more

I was inspired by a professional cake in a magazine and decided to attempt my own amateur version, and was delighted with the results and thought I would share this Pony Birthday Cake with anyone looking for great pony cake ideas. I used a Betty Crocker cake mix and 2 standard 9″ cake pans. I … Read more

This horse cake is a practice for my daughter’s 2nd birthday. She is getting a liberty horse, so I am planning a horse party. The birthday cake itself will have the true colors of the liberty horse, darker mane and tail, and the yellow around the blanket. I used a Wilton Carousel Horse cake pan, … Read more

My daughter loves horses and this year I decided to try and make her a Horse Birthday Cake Idea. I combined lots of ideas I found from other cakes on this site. I started by making (2) 9×13 chocolate cakes and cut each cake to make the horse. The frosting was fudge from a can … Read more

This Homemade Pony Cake was for my daughter Ava’s 4th Birthday. We went horse riding for the day and she had to have a pink pony cake. I made a regular sponge cake and cut the pony shape I drew out of it. I didn’t want to use too much food colouring so I iced … Read more

This is an Appaloosa horse cake made for my granddaughter’s 3rd birthday. She requested Horseland, but I thought the Horseland characters and horses weren’t as cute as this. Her mom did buy the Horseland pics to add to the cake. The horse’s body was made using the Wilton 3D Rubber Duck pan. I cut off … Read more